2026 St. John Real Estate Market Outlook: Stability, Strength, and Opportunity

Read the PDF Version Here>>>

In a national real estate landscape marked by volatility and uncertainty, St. John continues to stand out for its consistency. Over the past year, the island has once again proven itself as one of the most resilient real estate markets in the Caribbean, maintaining pricing stability, buyer confidence, and long-term desirability.

Post-COVID Pricing Normalizes — Without Distressed Selling

While many markets across the U.S. experienced significant price swings following the post-COVID surge, St. John’s market has adjusted in a far more controlled way. Sellers who initially priced properties at peak pandemic levels made appropriate adjustments, and correctly priced listings sold at true market value. Notably, the island did not experience distressed sales or below-market trades.

This is a key signal of market health and a reflection of St. John’s enduring demand from both U.S. mainland and international buyers.

A Balanced Environment for Both Buyers and Sellers

This moderation phase created a healthier and more balanced marketplace. Buyers are seeing more realistic pricing opportunities, while sellers aligned with today’s values are still achieving successful outcomes without sacrificing long-term equity.

Holiday Homes of St. John continues to lead the market, offering strategic marketing, deep local expertise, and advisory support for clients navigating shifting conditions.

2025 to 2026: Strength in the Numbers

As we head into 2026, data continues to support steady demand and meaningful activity. The island recorded:

  • 48 home sales (+11.6% year-over-year)

  • 9 condo sales (flat year-over-year)

  • 21 land sales (+34.4% year-over-year)

with the highest home sale closing at $10,500,000.

Total residential sales volume reached $79,525,500, condo sales totaled $8,405,000, and land sales added $3,054,000 to the market. These figures underscore a market that remains highly competitive, with strong interest across price categories.

Inventory Entering 2026: “Balance Meets Opportunity”

Following 2025, a portion of listings adjusted pricing heading into the new year, creating an opportunity-rich environment across multiple segments. Inventory remains active, and well-positioned properties continue to draw interest from buyers considering second homes, investment properties, or relocation.

Global Demand Remains a Driver

St. John benefits from a unique buyer pool that extends far beyond local demand. Limited supply, lifestyle appeal, and the island’s overall quality of life continue to support strong value preservation and long-term market stability.

Looking Ahead

With balanced pricing, steady demand, and a maturing post-COVID market, 2026 is shaping up to be another strong year for St. John real estate. For those considering buying, selling, or investing, this period represents a rare intersection where market balance meets opportunity.

Read the Full Newsletter Here>>>2026 Newsletter