Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white

Peter Bay Real Estate Prices, Photos, & Stats

Average Home Price: $6,437,000
View 9 Listings

Peter Bay Price Ranges

$4,500,000 - $8,999,500
4 Beds
$4,500,000 - $8,999,500
4 Listings
Single Family
$4,500,000 - $8,999,500
4 Listings
$750,000 - $1,595,000
5 Listings

What people like about Peter Bay

  • High-end luxury
  • Unprecedented north shore location
  • Adjacent to the island’s most beautiful beaches
  • Gated, exclusive enclave
  • Private beach access
Area Details

If it’s a high-end enclave you seek, look no further than Peter Bay. On St. John, this neighborhood is synonymous with the utmost level of luxury. This exclusive gated collection of palatial villas is nestled on the island’s picturesque north shore and framed by undeveloped National Park land. Owning in Peter Bay gives you the opportunity to be part of an exceptionally unique neighborhood with flawless taste.


Each home has been carefully designed by skilled architects and topped off with high-end finishes; many Peter Bay homes have been featured in the pages of magazines. The area’s landscaping has been thoughtfully manicured to reflect the utmost natural beauty. Peter Bay offers private access to a beautiful north shore beach which shares its name. Views from this neighborhood look out over renowned Cinnamon Bay and north to Jost Van Dyke.


Centrally located on one of the world’s most breathtakingly beautiful shorelines, Peter Bay is a stone’s throw from pristine Trunk Bay, and less than five minutes away from the island’s other alluring north shore beaches. Cruz Bay, with its wide range of shopping, bars, and restaurants, and charming Coral Bay are both about a 15-minute drive away. At the end of a day full of exploring St. John’s beauty, there is no finer place to return home to than Peter Bay.

Peter Bay Real Estate Market Stats

Follow the Market Updates on Peter Bay


Peter Bay

Local Info

St. John’s best beaches 10-15 minutes from Cruz Bay private beach

Successful bakery and coffee shop with potential for growth. From donuts to fresh pressed juices and smoothies St John Provisions has something for...

The Maria Bluff Estate

WELCOME TO MARIA BLUFF ESTATE!     Situated at the helm of Chocolate Hole, with 270 degree views, this home site was chosen in 1967 by General...

Beautiful Hansen Bay

  Dreaming of building your dream home on St. John? Look no further than the quiet and peaceful East End of St. john and the Hansen Bay community. This...

2022 Mid-Year Update

The St. John Real Estate Market remains very active for this first quarter of the year and early spring. From the 1st of January to the 31st of May, the...

2022 Newsletter

We are excited to share our 2022 newsletter!  Check it out for information on current market conditions, properties for sale, statistics from 2021, exciting...

New Luxury Condos Hit the Market!

NEW LUXURY CONDOS JUST LISTED! Sirenusa Villas Luxury meets modern island living at Sirenusa. Beautifully designed Villas built with privacy and functionality...

Peter Bay

Featured Listings

11 Peter Bay 1
25 Photos
12-2 Peter Bay 1
33 Photos
15-1 Peter Bay 1
39 Photos
4a & B Peter Bay 1
16 Photos
17-1 &17-2 Peter Bay 1
33 Photos
7-3 Peter Bay 1
19 Photos

By joining you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

International Partners