Artboard 1? alert-icon? Artboard 1? ? ? delete-icon? edit-icon? email-icon hide-hover-icon? Artboard 1? login-icon-white Artboard 1? next-icon-left next-icon-right-left next-icon-left-ochre next-icon next-icon-right-grey next-icon-right-ochre plus-with-circle-iconP search-fw-icon? search-icon-ochre search-icon-white

Fish Bay and Reef Bay Real Estate Prices, Photos, & Stats

Average Home Price: $1,892,000
View 15 Listings

Fish Bay and Reef Bay Price Ranges

$1,175,000 - $2,799,000
2 Beds
$1,175,000 - $1,349,000
2 Listings
3 Beds
$2,799,000 - $2,799,000
1 Listing
4 Beds
$2,245,000 - $2,245,000
1 Listing
Single Family
$1,175,000 - $2,799,000
4 Listings
$129,000 - $2,900,000
11 Listings

What people like about Fish Bay and Reef Bay

  • The neighborhood fringes a shark nursery
  • Most similar to stateside neighborhoods
  • Well-developed established area
  • Beautiful south shore views
  • Close enough, yet just far away enough from Cruz Bay
Area Details

Fish Bay on St. John’s south shore offers lovely ocean views, and is probably the area of the island that’s most comparable to a stateside neighborhood. In Fish Bay, the streets even have names! Nestled around the shoreline of the bay that shares its name, this neighborhood is a mix of longtime island residents and vacation rental villas.

Fish Bay is a known shark nursery. Wade into the shallow waters to see these beautiful creatures up close, or take in the sight from the beach or hillsides above if you’d rather not get up close and personal with sharks. The waters here are typically calm, making for great kayaking or paddle boarding. Beyond the bay, this neighborhood’s views are of St. Croix on a clear day on an otherwise unspoiled horizon.

Located no more than 15 minutes outside Cruz Bay, Fish Bay is close enough to the island’s main town to be convenient, yet far enough away that the atmosphere here is peaceful and secluded. The island’s famed north shore beaches are about a 20-minute drive away.

Keep traveling east through Fish Bay and you’ll arrive at Reef Bay, a large, wide, V-shaped stretch of coastline that is wild, unspoiled, and often deserted—except when there’s a south swell, which attracts a handful of surfers. The majority of Reef Bay is protected by the Virgin Islands National Park, so should you choose to purchase a home here, you’ll enjoy being one of the few who gets to call this remarkable, peaceful area home.

Fish Bay and Reef Bay Real Estate Market Stats

Follow the Market Updates on Fish Bay and Reef Bay


Fish Bay and Reef Bay

Local Info

Cruz Bay shopping, dining and stores Close to Marketplace (grocery store, video store, book/coffee shop, pharmacy, and more) Close to Westin Resort beaches snorkeling

LET'S DISCUSS: With our collaboration with Luxury Portfolio International (LPI), dive into the TOP FIVE ECONOMIC INSIGHTS FOR THE MONTH. Explore the latest...


Listing of the Day Location: St. John, U.S. Virgin Islands Price: $12 million Villa Indo is a bayfront Virgin Islands home with a private,...

Heaven’s Gate!

Heaven’s Gate: Named for its otherworldly setting, and breathtaking views.   Palm adorned gated drive, and stunning stone work are on display the...

Fish Bay and Reef Bay

Featured Listings

122 Fish Bay 1
38 Photos
5 Beds 4.5 Baths 5,380 Sqft
122 Fish Bay
Reef Bay, St. John
71-2 Fish Bay 1
74 Photos
71-6 Fish Bay 1
59 Photos

By joining you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy

International Partners